Evidence for prehistoric human dismemberment found at Carrowkeel

The prehistoric tomb at Carrowkeel (Cairn K)

A new analysis of bones taken from a century-old excavation at Carrowkeel in County Sligo has revealed evidence of the burial practices and death rites of the ancient people of Ireland.

The findings, which have been published in the journal Bioarchaeology International, are part of a project applying modern techniques and research questions to the human remains. The team of researchers includes Sam Moore, lecturer in Prehistoric Archaeology at IT Sligo, and the group’s work focused on the 5300 years-old Passage Tomb Complex at Carrowkeel. This site is one of the most impressive Neolithic ritual landscapes in Europe.

One of the 18 boxes re-discovered in the Duckworth Laboratory at the Leverhulme Centre for Human Evolutionary Studies, University of Cambridge, England

The bones were analysed from an original excavation of Carrowkeel in 1911, led by Prof R.A.S. McAlister,” explains Sam. “They were subsequently presumed missing or lost until a group of boxes with the name ‘Carrowkeel’ on them was discovered in the archive in the University of Cambridge in 2001. The bones date from between 3500 and 2900 BC.

The project was led by Dr Thomas Kador (University College London), with osteological research undertaken by Dr Jonny Geber from the Department of Anatomy at New Zealand’s University of Otago. The group also included Sligo based archaeologist Dr Robert Hensey and independent researcher Pádraig Meehan. The team analysed bones from seven passage tombs that included both unburnt and cremated human remains from around 40 individuals.

Cut marks on some of the human remains which were discovered at Carrowkeel Cut marks, marked in white (above) and magnified (below), observed on a left humerus (upper arm) from Cairn K (a), the ilium of a left coxae (part of pelvis) from Cairn K (b), and a right femur (upper leg) from Cairn K (c). Photo by Jonny Geber

Dr Geber says he and his colleagues determined that the unburnt bone displayed evidence of dismemberment. “We found indications of cut marks caused by stone tools at the site of tendon and ligament attachments around the major joints, such as the shoulder, elbow, hip and ankle“. Dr Geber suggests that the new evidence indicates that a complex burial rite was undertaken at Carrowkeel, which involved a funerary rite and placed a particular focus on the “deconstruction” of the body.

An Illustration of the anatomical location and distribution of cut marks on reassociated foot bones from Carrowkeel (unknown tomb context), involving a minimum of one left foot (a = dorsal aspect; b = medial aspect) and one right foot (c = dorsal aspect; d = plantar aspect). Shaded elements illustrate the bones that could be reassociated, and the darker shade the bones with evidence of cut marks. Illustration by Robert McPhee

So why would people in pre-historic Ireland have performed such rituals?

Attempting to understand the reasons these ancient communities dismembered the bodies is one of the real fascinations with this research,” says Sam Moore. “In the societies of the past, ancestry had more to do with group identity. This appears to have held real importance in Neolithic Ireland.

While evidence of similar prehistoric funerary rites has been uncovered in the UK, according to the investigation team this is the first definitive discovery of similar practices during the same period on the island of Ireland. The re-analysis of the bones uncovers high level of complexity and diversity of the funerary rites, which perhaps was not fully recognised previously.

The new study has been able to show that the Carrowkeel complex was a highly significant place in Neolithic society in Ireland, which had an important role in facilitating interaction with the dead and a spiritual connection with the ancestors.


6 thoughts on “Evidence for prehistoric human dismemberment found at Carrowkeel

  1. There were cut Mark’s discovered on numerous stone age remains found in the UK and it has been hypothesized that it was as a result of cannibalism. Waste not want not I guess!

    1. They were cut as part of a cremation ceremony , similar findings in Newgrange burial mound..no evidence of cannibalism Derek.

  2. This is fascinating stuff. Not happy with the fact that they originally were stored in an English university. I wonder what other Irish finds are stored out of the country.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.